eXtremeRate Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS5, for PS4 All Model Controller - Controller NOT Included

Feels almost identical to original joystick. Controller was easy enough to take apart to make the replacement. Would buy again.

My ps5 controller sticks wear often because I’m not gentle with my thumbs. After spending money on joystick covers of all types and brands - and never find any that didn’t fall off at one time or another - I decided to just buy these and couldn’t be happier that I did!The grip, color and feel all seem to be like the originals. Can’t tell which ones have been replaced without knowing.Durability actually seems to be a little better than original.Piece of cake to install. Just check to make sure they are moving freely as you reassemble controller (I found that over tightening some screws when putting controller back together can make the stick not move so just check as you go).Will buy again!

I have order this item twice in the month of September. Starting Sept 5th and again Sept 27th. As of now I have yet to even see the order SHIPPED much less actually receive it to give a proper review.I intend to change my rating once I receive what I paid for. Im sure it will work great with my LED kit for my controller, but until then I am very unsatisfied with this product.EDIT: I tried again and finally got em. Comes with everything in the picture and they work and fit perfectly. The hard translucent material its made of (i think they call it plastic) is perfect for me since all my other rubber analog sticks wear away or break to easily. Then you’re left with that sharp hard plastic underneath which is terrible for the games I play.This wont have that issue ever. Worth the wait. Now to get some more colors.

These thumbsticks are a fantastic upgrade for a PlayStation controller. The look, fit, and color are all top-notch, and they feel great in use. The only downside is the installation process, which is inherently a bit of a pain because of the way PlayStation controllers are designed. Taking the controller apart is the tricky part, not the thumbsticks themselves. If you're comfortable with a bit of DIY, these are highly recommended.Probably wouldn't recommend unless you are having issues with your current thumbsticks though.

Fits well altho snug on my Ally X, you have to somewhat squeeze it through the hole. Does not fit OG ally. But overall great feel grip wise.

My controller was messed up and dint wanna turn on with out being connected to the console, plus the thumb pads cushions broke off. So this fixed the controller basically reset it and made the control less rough or “sticky”

These fit perfectly on my Ally X. I ordered the clear ones and honestly I thought they were going to feel plasticy. However, these have a rubbery feel that's very comfortable for gaming.

As it turns out there are multiple generarions of ps5 dualsense controllers and these thumbsticks won't fit at least first generation dualsenses from my frustrating experience. I think there are better deals for thumbsticks on ebay.